My last two book club meetings of the year fell in the same week this month. Pudding and book club was Wednesday evening and the library book club on Thursday afternoon.
The book with the most votes last time at P&BC was A Bird In Winter by Louise Doughty. She was also the author of Apple Tree Yard which I read a few years ago and enjoyed, so I had high hopes for this one.

The story is about Heather, (aka bird), who works for the secret service, supposedly MI5. While in a meeting one day her boss says something that makes her feel as though she is in danger so she gets up and leaves the room and makes her way out of the building and collects the bag she has packed ready to leave should the need arise. We then follow her journey out of London and up through Scotland where she has maid arrangements to travel farther afield. The information on why she went on the run is drip fed in stages and I found the time line very hard to pin down because of the chopping and changing between past and present within the chapters. It's described as a thriller and although It started off well enough it just didn't really develop, if anything there were more questions than answers at the end.
It did however make for a very good discussion, most people chipped in with their interpretation of the ending, but on the whole we agreed that we would have liked more character development and a clearer timeline.
Jen, who took over running our B&P club a few months ago is a great host, at our October meeting she made some Boo baskets as raffle prizes, this time she made Christmas baskets for the raffle. She also wrapped a book for everyone and handmade crackers. There are 45 of us now in that group so she put in a lot of hard work for our last meeting of the year.
My wrapped book
Book Club Christmas raffle prizes
Shall I tell you how just lucky I am?
Well, there was three of us sat at a table last month, myself and two new ladies, one of them, Elaine,(such a lovely person and so funny), sat opposite me won one of the book prizes.
On Wednesday I sat with those same two ladies plus another new member.
Yet again I missed out, the other lady who joined last month won one of the Christmas baskets!
That's just about my luck😒
The next day was the library book club. There's a very different vibe to this meeting, all the ladies are older and we very often go off on a tangent, which is ok up to a point but sometimes it can get way off track (and one of them gets very uppity when that happens, lol). There is also one that dominates the discussion, which can be a bit overbearing sometimes but on the whole it's alright.
Our requested book didn't come through last time so we got this one off the main reading list.
Now if they had given this book out this Thursday I might have given it a go but we only had three weeks to read it and it was just over 800 pages long! Wasn't going to happen, not with everything else to do at this time of year.
I did say at the time that there was no way I was even going to attempt, but it would make a nice doorstop.
As it happened there was only myself and Wendy on Thursday, all the others had messaged to say they weren't going to make it for one reason or another, and hadn't read the book anyway. But fair play to Wendy she had managed to almost get to the end!
Perhaps is was best that there was only two of us this time it would have been upsetting if everyone had turned up because one of our members, Sue, passed away suddenly just a few days after our November meeting.
It was such a shock to everyone because as far as we know she hadn't been ill. She had been a member of that reading group since it started, so 15 years or more perhaps? I've only known her for perhaps four years but she was always friendly, she will be missed by everyone.
The first meeting in January will be strange without her.
-X-